Cave Syndrome Reviews

"As a lifelong resident of the Pacific Northwest, I have to say that it has been quite a while since I have heard anything as good as Transient Songs coming out of our backyard /
Transient Songs belongs in exalted company / A gorgeously nuanced album."
- SEATTLE P.I. / BLOG CRITICS
Show Full Review ||
Collapse Reivew
As a lifelong resident of the Pacific Northwest, I have to say that it has been quite a while since I have heard anything as good as Transient Songs coming out of our backyard. Cave Syndrome is the second album from the "group," which is actually a man by the name of John Frum and his occasional guests.
Cave Syndrome reminds me an awful lot of some of the best bands nobody ever heard in the early nineties. Groups such as Sadhappy, Adrian's Childhood, and Paisley Sin never caught a big-time record contract, but they were all great. Frum's music has something in common with each of them, but there is also a NW indie spirit about the disc that is reminiscent. The name of his record label alone is good for a chuckle: Indian Casino Records. His pop sensibilities are spot on too. The liner notes mention The Church and The Chameleons as influences, and the statement is certainly accurate.
The record begins with "In This Darkness Light Seeps Through," which despite the foreboding title is one of the more upbeat tunes. It strikes me as something Wayne Coyne might have come up with after an overdose of George Harrison's All Things Must Pass.
The trippiness, reverb and fog get deeper as the album progresses. "Smoking Slows The Healing" builds into a transcendent guitar frenzy that becomes absolutely hypnotizing, as does "Greenwood Backyards." The most fascinating song of all, though, is titled "The Cancer In Our Bloodlines." It is as if both The Church and The Chameleons decided to collaborate on a version of "A Day In The Life." The opening segment is a virtual Steve Kilbey carbon, while the latter portion would not have been out of place on side two of Script Of The Bridge.
John Frum hails from Texas originally, but we won't hold that against him. Especially as he had the good taste to enlist Chris Hanszek to master the disc. Hanszek founded C/Z Records back in 1985, and released the first collection of grunge, Deep Six shortly afterward. Transient Songs belong in such exalted company, and I hope that Cave Syndrome finds an audience. It is a gorgeously nuanced album.
http://blogcritics.org/music/article/music-review-transient-songs-cave-syndrome/
"Cave Syndrome is powerful and purging / A lofty, eclectic melange of an album
/ This is a rock solid piece of work in an era
when that is becoming a rarity. -
IMPOSE MAGAZINE, NY"
Show Full Review ||
Collapse Reivew
By Anthony Mark Happel » It is necessary to note right from the outset that this is not the new Mercury Rev album.
I say that because John Frum, the primary human component in Transient Songs, can sound so much like Jonathan Donahue of Mercury Rev it is possible to easily mistake this for something it is not. And, strange as this may sound, that actually turns out to be a compliment. There, that’s out of the way.
Frum is his own version of a one-man wrecking crew, since he plays almost everything on the record, with some guests joining him on cello, violin, bass, drums, and screams. The story is that he created this set of songs, over the course of the last year or so, by himself in his Seattle home studio (The Snakepit). Hence the hermetic title of the album.
He opens the album with a dynamite number entitled, “In this Darkness Light Seeps Through,” and its lofty, wandering melody line is the first confusing element in this eclectic melange. After the vocals really kick in there are moments when all the lines are blurred and you’re completely lost in the haze of everything that’s swirling around you. Then, he moves away from that initial core sound and pushes the jangly factor up a little more on “Smoking Slows the Healing.”
Some of this possesses a naturalistic, post-R.E.M. jangle-rock quality, and that washes over into another late 80s/early 90s stream that seems to carry with it some of the free spirit of a band like the Windbreakers. Frum, the lone wolf, avoids the “bedroom artist/bedroom athlete” syndrome by looking out of his lair toward the world, and by communicating more outwardly with his compositions; overall, it comes across as less brooding than some of his musical contemporaries, but still retains the powerful purging effect. This is a rock solid piece of work in an era when that is becoming a rarity.
http://www.imposemagazine.com/reviews/cave-syndrome--transient-songs
"The low key Seattle based continues to unveil high quality recordings that are unique in this saturated market of Northwest pop. There are equal parts Big Star and The Church incorporated into the new album with its woozy, late night atmosphere / One wishes there was more music like this in the current Seattle scene, but this also contributes to the unique, memorable and untrendy characteristics contained within Cave Syndrome.
"-
THREE IMAGINARY GIRLS,
Seattle (Cave Syndrome Review)
Show Full Review ||
Collapse Reivew
Opening with slide guitar reminiscent of "My Sweet Lord" from All Things Must Pass, the first solo album by George Harrison, Cave Syndrome, instantly takes off where previous EP, Plantation To Your Youth, left off. The low key Seattle based continues to unveil high quality recordings that are unique in this saturated market of Northwest pop. There are equal parts Big Star and The Church incorporated into the new album with its woozy, late night atmosphere.
Flourishes of vibrant psychedelic guitar canvass the straightforward songwriting of John Frum. This one is also close to home as there are numerous mentions of Northwest places in both the song titles and the lyrics. Cave Syndrome works well as a whole, but highlights include the all too short garage rock driven "Greenwood Backyards" and the stunningly gorgeous epic, "The Cancer In Our Bloodlines." Perhaps the albums apex, the track incorporates some beautiful violin playing by Amanda Lamprecht. The droning, dark shadows of "Golden Gardens" recall the location in the dead of winter when the bulk of the summer crowd has stayed away for some time. It's slow acoustic guitar rhythm provides the lonely sense of wonder and doubt that would occur if sitting on the deserted beach at sunset.
One wishes there was more music like this in the current Seattle scene, but this also contributes to the unique, memorable and untrendy characteristics contained within Cave Syndrome. That said, whether there were more bands like this around or not, Transient Songs produce some fantastic music that is worth your attention. This is the stuff of vintage guitars, a bottle of wine, some candles and then maybe a midnight drive through the wilderness. If this makes any sense to you, please purchase this record.
http://www.threeimaginarygirls.com/contentcdreview/2010mar/cave-syndrome
"This release is stunning/the arrangements are much more vibrant and seem to be
absolutely bursting with energy / You will want to put this one on again once it
has finished / it will only leave listeners wanting more and waiting to see just
where things go from here." -
COSMOS Magazine
Show Full Review || Hide Review
Early last year I was exposed to Transient Songs, a solo project started by singer/songwriter John Frum that offered a mix of psychedelic rock, shoegaze and retro rock and featured introspective lyrics and an overall spacey atmosphere. While the group’s debut EP Plantation to Your Youth wasn’t exactly the best genre release of 2008 it did have plenty of memorable moments and was more than enough to make quite a few people curious and anxious for more. And Frum has not kept them waiting too long, as Transient Song’s debut full length Cave Syndrome improves on every element showcased on the EP. It’s still a little too short, but this release is stunning and a real step forward for Frum’s musical career.
The instrumentals on Plantation to Your Youth were interesting, but sometimes it seemed as though they spent a little too much time building up atmosphere than they did creating ideas that really had some substance to them. This has been addressed on Cave Syndrome, as not only are the spacey atmospherics intact but the riffs are much more memorable and listeners are actually going to remember them this time around. In addition to this, John Frum had some additional mixing and mastering help and as a result the arrangements are much more vibrant and seem to be absolutely bursting with energy. There’s a little more emphasis on melodic shoegaze on this effort, but occasionally Transient Songs does head back towards traditional psychedelic rock territory. However, despite the fact that the songwriting is much better than before listeners will still be left wanting more as the entire effort only lasts for 36 minutes. You will want to put this one on again once it has finished, but it does fly by just a little too quickly.
One of the things I noted about Transient Song’s previous material was how John Frum’s vocal arrangements added to the overall atmosphere as he often sounded as though he was off in the background singing underneath of the instrumentals. For Cave Syndrome he has brought his singing into the spotlight, and while it still has the tendency to get lost amongst the melodic instrumental arrangements this sense of directness is appreciated and helps the songs to have an identity of their own. Admittedly the instrumentals are still what listeners will notice the most, so the solos on tracks such as “The Cancer in Our Bloodlines” is appreciated, but I would still like to see what Frum is capable of pulling off when he really pushes his voice.
Transient Songs was a decent act back in 2008, but it was clear that it was a bedroom project that still had some growing to do. With Cave Syndrome, it appears that transformation has begun to happen and as a result the material is much stronger and more memorable than before. It is slightly disappointing that the overall length is just over half an hour, but perhaps this was a deliberate move as it will only leave listeners wanting more and waiting to see just where things go from here.
Seattle-based dream-rock maker John Frum (Transient Songs) is set to release the debut full-length, Cave Syndrome, on May 25.
An earthy psychedelic sound reminiscent of Mercury Rev and Galaxie 500, expect Cave Syndrome to be something special.
POPMATTERS
Mournful, folky ballads that bespeak of long and lonely nighttime drives down dusty highways in the backcountry /
Transient Songs has crafted a good from-dusk-to-dawn record in Cave Syndrome, one inspired by the American troubadour tradition.
DRYVETYME ONLINE
Show Full Review || Hide Review
In my review of Plantation To Your Youth back in 2008, I wrote that, despite the band’s predilection for quality psychedelic Southern rock, the overall approach was a bit too fractured for me, which meant that there wasn’t much that stayed with me when the EP concluded. So, I was pleasantly surprised when I cracked open a preview copy of Cave Syndrome to hear that the group (now simply John Frum with some occasional collaborators) had retained its affection for The Byrds, Gram Parsons, and The Allman Brothers, while bringing in quite welcome spaghetti western tones and twinges of The Flaming Lips’ brand of psych-rock. The result is a more coherent full-length record that is decidedly more grown-up and structured.
Frum starts off the album with “In This Darkness Light Seeps Through” and “Smoking Slows The Healing,” two robust rock tunes that serve as a solid introduction to the record’s direction. With “Wide Open Skies” and “Golden Gardens,” we hear mournful, folky ballads that bespeak of long and lonely nighttime drives down dusty highways in the backcountry. It doesn’t hurt that there is some supple slide guitar and violin work on display casting a ghostly, ethereal mood across songs like “The Cancer In Our Bloodlines” and “A Burrow Patch.”
The only time that the record loses a bit of focus is with “Greenwoods Backyards” and “Astoria,” which are brief, under-two-minute attempts to slow down and/or shift the tone of the record. While I understand what Frum is trying to accomplish in those instances, they really just confused me and caused me to lose track of where the music was heading next.
In spite of those awkward transitions, I think that Transient Songs has crafted a good from-dusk-to-dawn record in Cave Syndrome, one inspired by both the American troubadour tradition and the classic American need to let off steam with a long, meditative drive. Just listen to the standout track “Sin Through The Summer” and tell me you don’t hear a classic, top-down, hair-blowing-in-the-wind road trip rock song.
http://www.dryvetymeonlyne.com/2010/04/26/transient-songs-cave-syndrome/
"Cave Syndrome's lush guitarscape evokes David Gilmore’s earlier work with Pink Floyd / If you’re in need
of a chill pill to get back in your groove,
Cave Syndrome is the right diagnosis for
what ails you." -
POPROCKET PRESS, Arizona
Show Full Review ||
Collapse Reivew
TRANSIENT SONGS
Cave Syndrome
Indian Casino Records
John Frum spent his punk years
in Texas before migrating to Seattle
and discovering the delights of 70s
psychedelic rock. Hooking up with multiinstrumentalist
Andy Gassaway, he’s
fleshed out Transient Songs with cellist
Ruth Davidson and violinist Amanda
Lempreicht for your full symphonic
enjoyment. A lush guitarscape evokes
David Gilmore’s earlier work with Pink
Floyd before Roger Waters steered the
band in a more populist direction on The
Wall. The free flowing, dreamy vibe makes
you want to hike out into the woods on
a warm summer evening and watch the
moon slowly work its way across the
night sky. Recreational accessories may
enhance the experience or could prove to
be entirely superfluous. If you’re in need
of a chill pill to get back in your groove,
Cave Syndrome is the right diagnosis for
what ails you.
PDF of copy, page 10
"Transient Songs employs elements of the psychedelic genre— dark lyrics, vocals and a wide, eclectic range of musical accompaniment— in a progressive, unique, soothing way/
Immersion in the music is key; otherwise you’ll be lost along the way." -REVUE
MAGAZINE,
(Michigan)
Show Full Review ||
Collapse Reivew
The band name is Transient Songs, the album is Cave Syndrome. Almost seems like it should be the other way around, but it’s not. Transient Songs was formed in Seattle based on a shared interest in ‘70s psychedelic music. John Frum (guitar, vocals) and Jimmy Andrews (bass, multi-instrumental) have taken this interest and made something new out. Slated for release in March 2010, the LP Cave Syndrome is a follow-up to the 2008 EP Plantation for Your Youth, both on Indian Casino Records.
Most closely defined as psychadelia, although not confined to the restraints of definition, Transient Songs has been compared to CSNY, The Byrds, post-sandbox Brian Williams, The Jesus and Mary Chain and others from the era that inspired them. However, emulation isn’t everything. Transient Songs employs elements of the psychedelic genre— dark lyrics, vocals and a wide, eclectic range of musical accompaniment— in a progressive, unique, soothing way.
Frum’s vocals are steadily monotone and emotionless throughout, leaving the words and music to do the job. Largely instrumental, the vocals tend to become a background to the music, including the usual bass and slide parts as well as string work (including cellist Ruth Davidson and violinist Amanda Lempreicht. Cave Syndrome is a definite product of place and genre, but the duo make it their own with the unique song-writing style of Frum and the wide ranging instrumentals of Andrews.
Disorienting, even disturbing at times, the sound of Cave Syndrome grows on you the more you listen to it. This album is best listened to lying on the floor surrounded by candles or incense to get the full effect. Immersion in the music is key; otherwise you’ll be lost along the way.
Barren soundscape and gurgling tumbleweeds / An undercurrent of CCR / Transient Songs delivers easy yet emotional songs that drift into a mellow dreaminess.
NOCTURNAL CULT
Show Full Review || Hide Review
An immediate reference to the laid back and thoughtful style of The Church can be heard on Cave Syndrome's opening track, In This Darkness Light Seeps Through. The sweet, whimsical notes that float to the surface also call to mind Belly at their most soulful moments. And so begins the journey that Transient Song take us along during the 10 tracks of their debut album Cave Syndrome. Heavy in self reflection and calm moments that give the listener room to breath and relax. A warbling western feel slowly shifts like desert sands on Smoking Slows the Healing as acoustic guitars and John's airy vocals paint a stark, dry night under the stars. A feeling of the sorrow and joy of homecoming after a long hard road is created by the piano on the opening passage of Greenwood Backyards before the second half develops in to more The Church leanings. Wide Open Skies with its echoing vocals and stumbling pacing creates a barren soundscape that drifts like white cloudy puffs on the horizon. Astoria is almost scary with its deep vocal tracts and disturbing shimmering guitars, like being in an underwater desert, gurgling tumblweeds ambling by with the current. The title track brings the journey to a close with moments of lighthearted-joy, a somewhat old school feel to it that brings a sort of a mix of 90s alternative with an undercurrent of CCR. If you love the expansive alternative sounds of The Church then Transient Songs will nestle into a warm spot in your heart. Though somewhat more diverse, Transient Songs delivers easy yet emotional songs that drift into a mellow dreaminess.
Plantation to your Youth EP Reviews

"There is a fresh sound on Plantation To Your Youth that is sorely lacking with a lot of modern bands / The vocals are upfront and impassioned, one thing that sets the band apart from much of the current wave of indie rock / There is a combination of raucousness and gentleness in these songs. The other thing that does this of course is the memorable songwriting / their songs are great and I would recommend this EP to anyone."
-
THREE IMAGINARY GIRLS, (Plantation to your Youth review, 2009:
Show Full Review || Collapse Reivew
Transient Songs is a local Seattle duo comprised of John Frum and Jimmy Andrews, who handle all of the instruments between the two of them. Their new five song EP is a solid collection of psychedelic garage rock in the vein of Neil Young and paisley underground bands such as The Rain Parade and Green on Red.
There is a fresh sound on Plantation To Your Youth that is sorely lacking with a lot of modern bands. The vocals are upfront and impassioned, one thing that sets the band apart from much of the current wave of indie rock. The other thing that does this of course is the memorable songwriting. There is a combination of raucousness and gentleness in the songs that is mastered quite well by the two core members of the group. On top of these two assets is the wonderfully warm sound of the EP. The production is stellar.
In fact, trying to pick a standout track from this collection of songs is difficult to do. All five of them are very good from the somber opener "Greenwood Backyards" to the straightforward, but slightly melancholy and still sonically interesting "Living With Decay." I would love to see how Transient Songs would sound in a live setting. Even an acoustic performance by Frum and Andrews alone would be intriguing. Their songs are great and I would recommend this EP to anyone.
"This release conjures forlorn vistas and cinematic undercurrents and world weary narratives / Navigates to the doobie-littered altars of Pink Floyd and the Byrds. Bleary, exquisite and wholly transcendental."
MEAN STREET MAGAZINE (San Diego):
Show Full Review || Collapse Reivew
Originating out of the hazy fog banks of the Pacific Northwest, garage psychedelic outfit Transient Songs (vocalist-guitarist John Frum and bassist Jimmy Andrews) and their five-song debut, Plantation to Your Youth, offer up a sublime resin-filtered journey through smoke-enshrouded byways and chiming guitars trails far beyond the lo-fi, burnout ethos of their basement origins. With enough jangly guitars for the Pavement/Magnet mag crowd and shimmering sheets of Jesus and Mary Chain-esque guitar squall and feedback, the release conjures up forlorn vistas, cinematic undercurrents and world-weary narratives ("Living with a ghost downstairs/And everywhere is never as green as it was back there") that navigate to the doobie-littered altars of Pink Floyd and the Byrds. Bleary, exquisite and wholly transcendental. - Mean Street Magazine
Grade: B+
ould sound in a live setting. Even an acoustic performance by Frum and Andrews alone would be intriguing. Their songs are great and I would recommend this EP to anyone.
"like the best psychedelic music, this stuff works like a new drug. / It's disorienting and maybe disturbing at first, but then it becomes addictive / Plantation to Your Youth is an EP that gets better the more you listen / one of my favorite releases of 2008"
-
PREFIX MAGAZINE
Show Full Review || Collapse Reivew
Getting right to the point, Transient Songs is a strange name for a band, and Plantation to Your Youth is a strange name for an EP. Hell, Plantation to Your Youth is a strange EP in itself. It's a pop-psychedelic mix of distorted guitars, low-fi production, and lyrics that are, by turns, dark, dreary and depressing. But like the best psychedelic music, this stuff works like a new drug. It s disorienting and maybe disturbing at first, but then it becomes addictive.
Plantation to Your Youth will probably wind up a forgotten artifact of indie music, because the duo apparently doesn t tour and doesn t seem part of any scene (although it carries on the tradition of garage sounds emanating from the Northwest). Still, the music got under my skin, largely because of the songwriting skills of Jimmy Andrews and John Frum (the latter of whom played guitar for Fort Worth, Texas, indie cult rockers Hasslehorse).
Most heavy music is based on riffs and shouting, but what these guys do is write sugary melodies and then pummel them with super-heavy arrangements (think the Fleet Foxes through a distortion pedal). This technique was pioneered by the early Who, carried on by the Clash and perfected by the Jesus and Mary Chain (the new Magnetic Fields album also takes this approach). The title track, for instance, lays a delicately plucked acoustic lead guitar atop what sounds like a half dozen snarling electric guitars playing rhythm parts. Southern City Saturdays starts with an acoustic guitar and vocal section before moving into an entirely unrelated main song -- after which it transitions back to the acoustic section for the ending.
The lyrics -- from what can be made out -- carry on the tradition of psychedelia in that they re impressionistic portraits of lives shattered by having to deal with, you know, reality, man. Some inspiring sample couplets: You ve got a heart that just won t quit/ And I ve got a head that s so full of shit and All the crying kids that you never had/ They had to get away and find their real dads.
Plantation to Your Youth is an EP that gets better the more you listen because more things bubble to the surface: half-heard drum parts, buried guitar harmonies, and choruses that start to take on different meanings. Anyone who rues the day Pro Tools became the industry standard way of recording will enjoy getting lost in these thickly textured mixes, which sound like they might have come off an old Ultimate Spinach or Move record.
- November 19, 2008
http://www.prefixmag.com/reviews/transient-songs/plantation-to-your-youth/22879/
"Effortlessly evokes the orchestral grandiosity of pre-sandpit Brian Wilson / Any comparisons probably won't do much to please Transient Songs themselves: their lyrics and dexterous musicianship really are entirely their own."
DOA (Delusions of Adequcy):
Show Full Review || Collapse Reivew
John Frum and Jimmy Andrews are specialising in what is a heady mixture of classic 80s (I swore I'd never use the word but here it is) Shoegaze - the surf harmonies, the downtuned fuzztone guitar harmonics, and borderline psychedelia that evokes the weightier end of the mid 80s Folkrock scene that gave us The Long Ryders and The Rain Parade - and an inescapable and unmistakeable songwriting debt to REM, which for all (or perhaps because of) REM's mainstream success throughout the 80s/90s and more recently, I don't ever really recall hearing too many bands on whom REM were a noticable influence, and it's taken my hearing Plantation To Your Youth to properly bring this to my attention.
So, if you think REM the great surreal countryfied stylists of the last two decades, would you necessarily appreciate Transient Songs? First track "Greenwood Backyards" is about a minute and a half of reverb laden semi-acoustic chords overlaid with keening mandolin and slide parts which, while its visceral energies recapture the machine grind of Snakedriver era JAMC, is really only an introduction to the title track, which both builds quite spectacularly on its abbreviated predecessor and displays some of the oblique lyrical touch of the best of REMs late 80s work. The song hangs around a great juddering wall-of-sound hookline that effortlessly evokes the orchestral grandiosity of pre-sandpit Brian Wilson, and the heavily layered production takes what is the most basic three chord structure to a quite staggering conclusion. Following on from this, "Southern City Saturdays" is most obviously the track which could slip unnoticed into an REM b-sides collection, a relatively more restrained acoustic based song. This is followed with "Locust Shells", which has an undeniable late 60s feel to both its structure and instrumentation, shares the majestic production style of the title track, and takes a detour quite firmly into Scott Walker territories. Final track "Living With Decay" is also, there is little doubt in my mind, a quite definite echo of some of those lesser known Stipe/Buck/Mills/Berry compositions, REM being a very good example of the type of band whose work I think I know, and were the track released as a single today it might do something similar to what is my own favourite REM semi-obscurity, "Lotus",which made 36 in the UK charts around a decade ago.
But all these comparisons probably won't do much to please Transient Songs themselves: their hard-lived lyrics and dextrous musicianship really are entirely their own.
-Jon Gordon - DOA 10/29/08
"5 Songs awash in dusty ambience and jangly psychedelia / Equal parts Roger McGuinn, CSNY and latter day Grant Lee Phillips / Lay on the floor and enjoy it."
- METRO SPIRIT, Augusta GA
Show Full Review || Collapse Reivew
The five songs that comprise Plantation to Your Youth are awash with garage-dust ambience and the kind of jangly psychedelia that invokes the little sunshine seen by that city as much as its oft-cited gloomy dampness
equal parts Roger McGuinn, CSNY, and latter-day Grant Lee Phillips, with dashes of Echo and the Bunnymen, These United States, and para-dimensional backporch The Edge create a tasty morsel that will tingle, if slightly confuse, your palate think Pop Rocks and Guinness. Then lay on the floor and enjoy it -
"Plantation To Your Youth jangles like the Byrds on steroids and human growth hormone rendered in grand Floydian style"
-FORT WORTH WEEKLY
Show Full Review || Collapse Reivew
It seems wholly appropriate that this music should originate in the PacNW, where garage psychedelia never seems to go out of fashion. Plantation To Your Youth jangles like the Byrds on steroids and human growth hormone rendered in grand Floydian style
-Ken Shimamoto - Ft. Worth Weekly
|